I've tried Peak's, Cajun Candle's, NG's, and have a sample of ICS and one on the way from Scent Works. I'm on a quest for the best Pink Sugar!!! So far, I'd have to say NG has it best. The only problem is their's is a tad softer than the others in terms of throw. Peak's is a close second. However, there is something slightly harsh in the Peak's version. It didn't do well in my cyclo spray, but works well in everything else. But NG is fine with cyclo. But as I said, it's a bit softer than I'd like. Cajun's is not even close! Yuck! ICS smells just like NG and Peaks oob. So unless SW version is better than NG, I'm sticking with NG!