Okay out of bottle smell so far for the following are: Cinnamon Stick - Yum Citrus & Sage - Dead on Dupe, definately a keeper Ylang Ylang Ginger - meh not what I expected Vanilla Hazelnut Mocha - Yum Twigs & Berries - meh not what I expected, but may smell different in the wax French Vanilla - Yum, thinking of mixing this with the cinnamon stick Spanish Melon - meh Eucalyptus Mist - Yum definately a keeper, great soap scent, maybe even for shaving soap. Plum Crazy - meh, not enough spice, i may try their spiced plum instead. Mountain Lake - Yum this will replace my other mountain lake for soaping. Lilac Breeze - yum Litsea & Basil - okay, hoping this blossoms in the wax or soap. Dream Catcher - yum, this will be great in soap Raspberry Guava - double yum, thinking of mixing this one with Lilac or Patchouli.